Best Execution Guidelines for Fixed-Income Securities

Published on:
September 1, 2008

SIFMA’s Asset Management Group (SIFMA AMG) published best execution guidelines for fixed-income securities.

Download Report

Excerpt

Background

It has long been acknowledged that an asset management firm is a fiduciary subject to a number of duties when acting on behalf of its clients. Among the most important of these duties is the requirement that an asset manager seek “best execution.” Best execution is not formally defined in the U.S. federal securities laws and securities industry participants are not uniform in their definition of the term. Industry participants and regulators seem to agree that best execution contemplates an asset manager’s executing securities transactions on behalf of a client with the goal of maximizing value for the client under the particular circumstances occurring at the time of a transaction, and generally acknowledge that best execution is not easily quantifiable and encompasses many factors.

Much of the existing guidance regarding an asset manager’s duty to seek best execution has been developed in the context of equity securities and the equity markets. Significant differences exist, however, between the equity and fixed-income markets. A far greater number and far more types of instruments, for example, trade on fixedincome markets than on equity markets. The fixed income markets are characterized by bilateral transactions between parties as principals as opposed to equity markets in which transactions are undertaken on centralized exchanges facilitated by agents. Unlike their equity counterparts, fixed-income markets are fragmented and often subject to limited transparency as a result of the absence of a centralized reporting mechanism for completed transactions.

It is clear that the duty to seek best execution imposed on an asset manager is the same regardless of whether the manager is undertaking equity or fixed-income transactions. The characteristics of the fixed-income markets present a manager with practical difficulties, though, in assessing and documenting fixed-income best execution not faced when undertaking equity transactions. These difficulties in turn result in significant challenges to an asset management firm when developing, and regulators when evaluating, policies and procedures designed to ensure compliance with the duty of best execution of fixed-income security transactions. The lack of existing practical guidance regarding that duty exacerbates the challenges.

Details

More Content

  • Guides & Playbooks
    Oct 06, 2026

    Third-Party Resilience: Increasing Transparency

    SIFMA and Protiviti examine third-party resilience as frontier AI reshapes cyber threats and increases risks across financial services.
  • Market Practices and Model Documentation
    Jul 30, 2026

    Treasury Clearing Documentation

    To provide market efficiency, particularly as more entities come into the clearing ecosystem, SIFMA has convened representatives from both the buy- and sell-side in working groups to develop market standard documentation. Market standard documentation for the “Done-With” model is now available. The “Done-Away” model will require changes to market structure. As part of our efforts, SIFMA’s working groups will identify those needs.
  • Readiness Exercises
    Jul 29, 2026

    Industry-Wide Business Continuity Test

Get the latest trends, stats, and research on financial markets and securities.