Responsible Innovation and Market Modernization

In a new episode of The SIFMA Podcast, SIFMA President and CEO Ken Bentsen brings together two conversations from SIFMA’s 2026 Annual Meeting featuring CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig and SEC leaders Jamie Selway and Sebastian Gomez Abero.
The discussions explore how the CFTC and SEC are approaching responsible innovation and market modernization, from tokenized securities, evolving market structures, and extended trading to capital formation, Treasury clearing, and coordination across regulators.
You can listen to this conversation by following “The SIFMA Podcast” on Apple, Spotify, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts. Sign up to receive new episodes, delivered right to your inbox.
In This Episode
- Regulatory modernization and evolving market oversight
- Digital assets, tokenization and emerging financial products
- Market structure changes and the future of 24/7 trading
- SEC-CFTC coordination and regulatory harmonization
- Capital formation, disclosure reform and access to private markets
- Treasury clearing implementation and industry readiness
Featured Guests
Sebastian Gomez-Avero
Deputy Director for Legal and Regulatory Policy, Division of Corporation Finance
SEC
Michael Selig
Chairman
CFTC
Jamie Selway
Director, Division of Trading and Markets
SEC
Transcript
Kenneth E. Bentsen Jr.: Welcome to the SIFMA Podcast. I’m Ken Bentsen, President and CEO of SIFMA. Today’s episode brings you two conversations from SIFMA’s 2026 annual meeting focus on responsible innovation and the modernization of U.S. capital markets. Markets are evolving quickly. Tokenization, new products, extended trade, and changing market infrastructure are creating new opportunities, while also raising important considerations over regulation, investor protection, and market resilience. The challenge is not simply more or less regulation, it’s ensuring that regulatory frameworks remain calibrated to the markets and risks they are designed to address, supporting responsible innovation while we’re protecting investors and market participants, preserving market integrity, and enabling our capital markets to fulfill their fundamental purpose driving capital formation, job creation, and economic growth.
In this episode, we hear directly from leaders of the CFTC and FEC about how they are approaching that analysis. We begin with CFTC Chairman Michael Selling. Chairman Selling discusses the Commission’s approach on responsible innovation and the importance of modernizing regulatory frameworks as markets and technology evolved. He describes an approach centered on what he calls the minimum effective dose of regulation to maintain fundamental protections while right sizing legacy requirements that may no longer reflect the markets in government. The conversation also explores coordination between the CFTC and SEC of volume market structures and the role regulatory clarity can play in supporting innovation while maintaining strong and resilient markets. Let’s listen.
First of all, thank you so much for being here. And you’ve got a busy schedule, and so we really appreciate having you spend some time with us. You’ve got a busy agenda with uh with so much going on. Um, you were sworn in as chairman of the CFTC last December, uh returning to the agency where you started your career as a law clerk. Um you’ve hit the ground running. Uh you know, looking back on the your first 10 months, what do you think is most top of mind today? What’s the most what’s your pri top priority today?
Michael Selig: Well, when I came into the seat, I recognize that our markets have changed so much from, of course, when I was back at the commission years ago, but really over the past couple years, even, we’ve seen so much transformation, whether it’s crypto and blockchain technology, superintelligence, new products, things like perpetual contracts and prediction markets. And coming into the seed, I recognize that there’s a lot that is happening offshore. There’s a lot that’s happening on these blockchain-based networks that is interesting. There’s a lot of product design choices that these firms are making that maybe works very well. If you read some of Matt Levine’s columns, he said, you know, maybe 99% of it doesn’t work, but there’s that 1% that’s really interesting. Um, and so we need to create a path for that in the United States, but we need to do it with rules and regulations and make sure that we lead in innovation, but also in responsible innovation, making sure that there’s rules and regulations, guardrails around all of that. So coming into the seat over the past 10 months, you know, a lot of what I’ve done is evaluating these products, try to create pathways for them to come into the United States, and then also looking at what we have from the Dodd-Frank Act era. There was a lot that was really appropriate and has worked very well, uh, putting things into central clearing, having swap data reporting, um, making sure that we have uh you know a robust regime around over-the-counter swaps, but there’s also a lot that it’s working, it’s there, uh, but it doesn’t really need to be there. It’s sort of a um an appendage. And so we’re evaluating what has worked well, what hasn’t worked well, things like swap data reporting. There’s a lot of fields, a lot of the firms in the marketplace, I’m sure, have been dinged for uh missing a field or two, and we want to make sure that what we’ve got in place works well and it’s necessary, that it’s it’s right-sized approach, the minimum effective dose of regulation.
Bentsen: Yeah, that’s a lot. I mean, uh I want to I want to come back to the uh tokenization, but I do want to say when you think about all that the CFTC has done since the passage of Dodd-Frank, I mean, it it’s it’s the volume or the exponential increase in the its rule book, um, you know, you could argue it’s it’s worth the time to sort of step back and say, okay, now what worked, what didn’t work, and and how can we, to your point, right size? Um you have uh recent action at the CFTC uh, you know, after the Clarity Act has stalled out in the Senate, we’ll see what happens to that. You said the CFTC would move ahead on uh crypto market structure using your existing authority, and you published uh uh an AM published an AMPR of two proposals or you know, announced that you’re gonna put out two uh rulemaking proposals on crypto asset transactions and markets respectively. Um and uh um I saw you on CNBC, in fact, uh uh talking about this the day after you did that. What what do you think, what what are you hoping that those proposals will do and and what are the limits that you have without legislation?
Selig: Well, I’m disappointed that we didn’t get crypto asset market structure legislation to the president’s desk because I think that would have been the surest way, the most future-proof way to make sure that we have a market structure here in the United States that protects American investors and consumers in the crypto space, and also requires that we have market-based rules and regulations around these exchanges. For so long, and they’ve existed under these state laws and regulations that are designed for payment services, right? Things like Western Union and Venmo, and it works somewhat for these marketplaces, but it’s not really purpose-fit. It’s really uh, you know, if you think about get off the airplane in a foreign country and you see the check cachers and the um the exchangers of currency, you know, that’s not the same thing as when you go onto a crypto exchange and you custody assets and move those uh and trade them on an order book. So we really need market-based regulation. And the CFDC has a lot of authority, the SEC has a lot of authority under our existing statutes, but of course, it doesn’t require crypto asset exchanges to register with us. Certain types of exchanges, yes, but the vast majority of these exchanges aren’t mandated to register with us as they operate today. Um, what we do have authority to do is say if you want to offer margin leverage or financing to retail customers, what’s been referred to in our statute as retail commodity transactions, and this is authority given to us under Dodd-Frank, and it solved this so-called Zeldner loophole that over the many years there were these platforms offering the effectively these futures contracts light, where you can purchase precious metals or foreign currencies and roll the transactions over and you’re never receiving actual delivery of that. It’s just a book entry on some platform, and you’re able to access margin leverager financing. You don’t have to accept it, but of course it’s it’s available to you. And the same looks true of a lot of these crypto exchanges offshore, where you’re able to trade crypto products on margin, leverage, or financing. The assets are actually held in an omnibus wallet, so it doesn’t go to your external uh self-custodial wallet that you can move assets freely. It’s actually uh a sub-account within an omnibus wallet, and so it’s effectively a book entry. So we can have that model here in the United States, but unfortunately we don’t have the rules for it. And so that’s exactly what we’re doing. We’re putting in place rules and regulations instead of just weaponizing those provisions against many of these exchanges as prior administrations have done. We’re writing the rules and we expect firms to comply. If they want this federal option, they can come in and register either as a designated contract market. So this enables many of the existing crypto exchanges that actually have these marketplaces registered with the CFDC to leverage this on day one, or they would be able to obtain a license as a subcategory of DCM called a crypto asset market or a CAM. And these are purpose-fit registration regimes. It looks closer to what you see with the uh registration processes at the state level, except that it it is more in line with our framework, right? It’s going to allow for uh vertical integration under our rules, but you’ve got to have separate entities. So it would be or separate registrations. So you’d need an FCM, you would need a DCM or the CAM, uh, and then you would also need a clearinghouse and DCO. So it’s it’s it’s very much akin to what you see under our existing regime, but we will be providing for purpose fit regulation. Of course, we have a principles-based framework at the CFTC, uh, unlike the SEC’s framework. So we allow for more flexibility, which I think is perfect for these crypto markets. But of course, there are certain core principles that uh are requirements, things like you can’t list a contract or a trade that’s readily susceptible to manipulation. So we’ll be looking for things like that. We’ll be instituting listing standards. So you can think of this as a an outgrowth of our existing regime that is going to allow for a federal option for crypto exchanges that choose to register with us, but again, it’s an option. Um you don’t have to come in and register with the CFTC.
Bentsen: And and and will uh uh a crypto exchange that that volunteers to register, will they then be self-designating the crypto asset, whatever it may be, as a commodity under the Commodities Exchange Act, like voluntarily, effectively?
Selig: That’s exactly right. So we have listing standards for our contracts as it stands today, and we will have similar listing standards for crypto assets that would trade on our markets. Of course, we don’t offer trading in securities, so these contracts and and products would have to be commodity products, uh, and and we’d also be looking at their susceptibility to manipulation, and that goes to things like, for example, you know, we we’ve designated meme coins as a type of digital collectible. Some of these meme coins have very thin trading or a large supply that’s held back by the issuer. So we would look at all of that when a firm comes to us and wants to list that product for trading.
Bentsen: And obviously you’re just you you you’re just put these out. I mean, I don’t know if they’ve if they’ve actually published in the register yet or not. But do you yeah, are you getting any indication of of interest from the from the from the exchanges?
Selig: So far the interest has been uh you know great. I think there are a lot of firms, as I mentioned, that already have designated contract market registrations with us or futures commission merchants or uh derivatives clearing organizations. So they like the fact that they can leverage that right away and start listing new products. And you know, when you’re able to buy and sell these tokenized assets on the platform, you can also leverage them as collateral for other types of positions. So I think it fits really well with everything else that we’re doing on tokenization and with new contracts like perpetual futures and other types of options, as well as the security futures and and security perpetual product work that we’re doing with the SEC. So I think it just you know it adds another dynamic to the marketplace, gives people the ability to go purchase tokenized assets, not just you know, import them from another place.
Bentsen: And I mean, but it sounds like you still see legislation uh is the best long-term answer. I mean, you don’t I mean this the this voluntary uh uh uh registration doesn’t give you um doesn’t expand your uh authority with respect to spot commodity markets investor protection rules that right that that you don’t currently lack, you have anti-fraud rules, anti-manipulation rules, but but you don’t have a similar regime that similar to what the SEC has, that in some parts the legislation was trying to address. So you still see legislation as the best outcome.
Selig: I do remain concerned that if you allow for some of these exchanges to be licensed at the state level, look, there are states like Montana that don’t even have a money transmitter licensing framework. So some states don’t even license the exchanges. If you allow for these exchanges to remain licensed at the state level, these regimes really are designed for payment businesses. They’re not designed for markets, for exchanges, so they don’t necessarily police for things like wash trading. We’re supposed to do that, of course, at the federal level because we uh you know are the regulator of the spot markets when it comes to fraud and manipulation. Um, but generally speaking, we don’t get all the order book data from every single exchange. We’re not looking over these exchanges in the same way that you would if they were registered with us. And secondarily, the National Futures Association, of course, is a self-regulatory organization that oversees the brokers in our markets. So we have special information and the ability to work together with the NFA on regulating the futures commission merchants that onboard the customers. We don’t have that relationship with the state uh licensed money transmitters, and also they’re not self-regulatory organizations in the same way that our exchanges and clearinghouses are. So I think there are a lot of gaps and issues that if you allow for these two parallel regimes, I do think having a federal option will set the gold standard, and many of the states will try to mirror that in their state licensing frameworks, but it does create some gaps, and I am concerned that you know we’re four years out from the FTX collapse, and FTX had a bunch of state money transmitter licenses. Those entities still failed. The one uh set of entities that actually survived and had the funds protected were the CFTC license entities. Uh, and those were offering derivatives contracts, of course. But um so I I do think the regulations work, and if we apply these same sites types of rules to the crypto markets, it’s going to protect customers and make sure that uh these markets really are something that you can go move your money onto and feel safe. Uh, but I am concerned that there’s going to be some gaps at the state level.
Bentsen: So let’s let’s switch over to uh uh tokenization. Um you you you’ve said markets need to prepare for quote unquote mass tokenization, and the CFTC has issued uh no action positions and FAQs related to crypto assets and blockchain technologies. One of the most promising use cases uh for tokenized assets, uh be they treasuries, money market funds, or payment stable coins, is margin collateral. What are the next steps uh from your perspective on tokenized collateral?
Selig: Well, tokenization invites a number of really unique considerations for a regulator. So tokenized assets can trade on-chain 24-7, 365. They’re able to be programmed in connection with smart contracts. So you can move these assets, you can program them uh 24-7 all year round. And as a regulator, of course, our markets have for so long largely been confined to certain trading hours, and the assets really sit on the book of some custodian or record keeper. Um, so there’s not really this ability to just move assets so freely, to program them, to use them in connection with different types of applications. And you also have this whole world of a decentralized finance where people are developing novel applications, smart contracts that these tokens can interact with. So what we’re looking at in terms of margin and allowing for tokenization to work within our platform is marrying the two worlds together. So we are we’re looking, and I’m sure we’ll get into 24-7, so I won’t spend too much time on that now. But uh considering whether if we’re allowing for this ability to move tokenized assets over the weekend, how does that free up the ability and make uh margin movement much more efficient? So uh when you’re you’re offering 24-7 markets now or weekend trading, typically what happens is you’re over-collateralizing, you’re moving more assets into your collateral on a Friday so you have sufficient collateral to trade over the weekend. Um, with stable coins and other types of tokenized assets, you can freely move them just like you would during regular trading hours. And I think that is a huge advantage. We’ve also seen issues with banks, and during certain hours, there’s outages or uh the SVB collapse is a great example where there’s concern about funds being able to move and pulling your assets out. These types of assets, of course, uh exist on a blockchain, they’re able to move much more freely. Um area that we’re coordinating with the SEC on that I think is really important to allow for this to work on our side is a lot of these tokenized assets that are trading now in the more regulated space, I’ll call it, are tokenized securities. So the SEC has done a ton of great work in getting an innovation exemption out. They’ve also uh provided relief to the DTC to be able to offer tokenized securities, and so I expect to start seeing those being used as collateral within our markets and of course on the security side. So we’re working closely with the SEC to make sure that that’s harmonized. Um but but tokenized collateral, I think, opens up just a lot of mobility and the ability to program things. You know, if people want to utilize smart contracts, we’re trying to create that space working together uh with the software developers to figure out how these on-chain systems work, if relief’s needed, what sort of relief’s needed. And so, you know, I view this as a really exciting opportunity to to bring more liquidity into our markets and to make capital much more efficient.
Bentsen: Yeah, I think I think what we hear um is uh you know what we might call digital money, um uh the fungibility of it, the ability to your point of being able to move collateral quickly um uh um can be a can be quite valuable to the TradFi world, if you will. But on 24-7, I mean that’s a key component as well, right? Of uh of a 24-7 uh uh trading environment. But there are other issues as well. I mean, how you know there are issues around clearing, uh, there’s issues not necessarily in as much of the CFTC world as the SEC world around you know corporate actions, dividend payments. But how how are you how is the CFTC thinking about more more generally or more broadly on 24-7 trading and and how how you would oversee that?
Selig: Yeah, I think I said this in my confirmation hearing. So really since day one, I’ve said it’s not gonna be a one-size-fits-all approach for 24-7 at the CFTC, and we’ve done exactly that. We’ve made sure that for those assets where it’s suitable today and it makes sense and there’s real demand, we’ve allowed for 24-7 trading. So that includes things like crypto, uh prediction markets largely, uh, some prediction markets we we’ve kept to normal trading hours, um, you know, some of the financial products out there, precious metals. So we we’ve kind of bucketed all of that. If you look to our statute, we actually have a defined category of commodities for agricultural commodities. You know, these are products that really there’s concern about 24-7 trading, and I think our statute gives us a lot of discretion to say these commodities are different. They’ve been distinguished. Actually, if you go back to the 20s, of course, our statute uh was just for agricultural commodities and it’s expanded over the years, but a lot of the rationale for 24-7, it’s it’s not for many of these commercial firms. They’re not too excited about it, but it is for a lot of the financial products. So we’ve taken two different paths when it comes to energy, uh, that’ll also group with these agricultural products, where you know, you I’m sure many of you have seen uh some firms like CME have tried to list those products and they’ve been very cooperative with us because there’s been concern from industry, and so we’ve got to work through that before we allow some of these products to come to market. And so CME, you know, did a great job putting that product out there and then um withdrawing that just so we can make sure that the industry is ready. Um, and one point I’ll underscore is that you know we can only hold up these products for so long. If there’s a ton of demand and and firms try to lift list these products, you know, we’re gonna evaluate it, we’re gonna certainly do our diligence and and to the extent we need to propose new rules or work together with the Hill to make sure that there’s a framework in place to protect uh investors and making sure that products don’t come to market before there’s um you know the the the you know we’re not gonna have issues kind of impacting uh commercial markets and that sort of thing. Um so we’ll we’ll certainly look to that and make sure we we do things right. But at the same time, if this is coming, I think firms need to start preparing for that. And that means you know, thinking about operational staff, uh the systems that need to be in place, uh expanding the staffing during off hours, that sort of thing. So we’ve also been working together with a lot of these trading firms just to make sure they’re prepared for it. And what do they need from us? What sort of rules and regulations should we be thinking about to prepare for that? Uh but again, uh, you know, I think it’s worked very well for certain commodity classes, for others, there’s just real concern. Um, you know, we even saw negative oil pricing uh during COVID. You know, if you get that during 24-7, it’s a lot worse than during normal trading hours. So firms are rightfully concerned, and we’re gonna work with them to hopefully get that right. I think on the security side, as you mentioned, very different concerns, and um, we are seeing a lot of these security futures products coming to market. CME now has its security futures, uh, Coinbase and others have uh started the process to list security futures perpetuals. Um we’re excited about that. We’re gonna work with the SEC to make sure that we mirror what they uh are doing on the security side uh in our DCM markets with uh security futures.
Bentsen: So we’ll so so to your point, I mean I know we at Sithna are working with our members on a lot of issues, particularly in our ops group and our equities and options groups around um preparing for 24-7 or 23-5 that we’ll have you know will go into place uh um uh or a new iteration will go into place at the it towards the end of this year. We’ll see if the market follows, but but nonetheless, we we feel duty bound to be prepared for it and and we’ll see how volumes uh how volumes evolve. I will we’ll Well I want to come back to products, but before I do, I I do want to talk about AI, AI and market safeguards. Um, you know, the next market disruption may not come from a fat finger era, but could come from autonomous AI systems, you know, working as design, possibly through a weekend, uh uh when not all markets are 24-7 or or or maybe close. How are you know how should regulators and firms think about circuit breakers in in a situation like that? Do we just take the existing, well, we used it for fat finger and and we got through that, or or or should we be thinking differently?
Selig: Well, we’ll have to correct you on AI, uh, because I believe it’s now SIM just playing around. Um so when it comes to artificial intelligence and superintelligence, um what we’re looking at are, of course, our existing mandate to police the markets, make sure that the markets are operating efficiently, that there are um clear rules of the road for firms that want to innovate with new technologies. But we also have to recognize as a regulator, you know, our mandate is is limited. So we don’t cover the gamut of every uh individual that chooses to use software to enhance their trading activity. Um and in a world where everybody every day is using these applications to do all sorts of things. You know, I I imagine if I open up my phone and and others open up their phones, you know, you’re gonna find all these applications that are powered by SI or AI on the back end, even if you’re not using uh a chat bot program. So uh you know this technology is becoming incredibly pervasive, and it’s something that our registrants are, of course, rolling out in various ways. So we are seeing commodity trading advisors and other registrants start to offer capabilities that that uh utilize AI and SI for trading and that sort of thing, or advising customers. Um, so it’s so it’s an important consideration, and we’re certainly going to work with our registrants to make sure that what they’re offering is compliant with our rules and regulations and consider whether we need to upgrade those or change those rules to account for the technology to modernize those. And you know, as I mentioned at the outset, we’ve got principles-based regulation, which gives us a lot of flexibility there, gives firms a lot of flexibility as well to experiment. Um, when we’re looking at trading on our exchanges, uh, of course, we’re gonna be cognizant of trading utilizing these types of strategies. We’ve been familiar with it for a long time. Of course, the proprietary trading firms and others have been utilizing algorithmic uh technologies and software to trade for for a very long time now. And it’s caused issues, it’s also worked largely fine. Um so we’re going to monitor for that and see how it works when retail and others start to utilize it. Our markets historically have been more institutional, but we’re seeing a ton of retail activity, uh, in particular when it comes to prediction markets and crypto and some of these new products. So we’re monitoring for all of that. But as regulators, you know, I think we have to regulate uh, of course, the activity in our regulated markets and our in our registrant uh categories, but when it comes to individuals, they’re gonna use these technologies no matter what, right? Somebody is going to download Claude or Chat GPT or one of these programs, and they may be able to use it to develop a trading strategy and then go implement that on the back end. And even that that’s even if it doesn’t connect to their broker or their their exchange software. So we recognize that. I think we want to come up with a framework that allows for innovation, allows people the freedom to utilize AI and to come up with their own uh innovative trading strategies. But of course, when it’s plugged into one of our registered systems, we’re gonna be looking at that, and we’re also going to have to be more cognizant in our surveillance efforts and our working together with the exchanges to make sure that to the extent circuit breakers are needed, for example, in a fat finger instance, as you mentioned, or um, you know, the flash crash many years ago, you know, all these sorts of um catastrophes can be uh the result of a very small uh you know movement in the market using uh one of these technologies. So we’re cognizant of that, uh, but at the same time, we’re working, we’re learning, we’re trying to figure out a path that allows for the most innovation without uh harming customers and the markets.
Bentsen: Yeah, just thinking of it from the standpoint uh I mean you wear a lot of hats as the chairman of the of the commission and one of its, you know, your manager, and you’re having to think about you know your resources and your and all that. Are are you are you seeing, and uh you know, this is something where you’re having to build up. I mean, the the commission’s lean and mean, you got a lot of very smart people over there, but you know, keeping up with technology and thinking about how you’re you know staffing out the the place.
Selig: We absolutely are leveraging superintelligence throughout the buildings. We’ve rolled out a number of programs, including the ones I mentioned, things like CLOD and cowork and all of that, which uh are are really allowing us to do a whole lot more. I think staff throughout the building are very excited about these software products. Um and we’re also building some of our own um AI-based products that will leverage in the enforcement and surveillance space. So that’s allowed us to do a ton more. I think one of the staff the other day told me this is something that would have taken them a week or two weeks, and they just did it in less than an hour. Um, so so that’s really terrific, but of course, that’s no substitute for having uh staff within the building, and we’ve done a great job building that back up. Of course, I came into the position about a year ago now, um, and and from day one we’ve been building up the staffing. So that’s really important for us to do our job. But the CFDC really is in a unique place in that uh since day one, since the agency was formed in the 70s, we’ve really leveraged the ability to uh rely on the exchanges as self-regulatory organizations. So if you look back to our budget way back then, it was even way smaller than you would expect for a regulator of the time. And uh that’s in large part because the exchanges do such a great job policing their markets. So they’re of course surveilling their markets, they are bringing their own enforcement actions, um, and and many of these have done uh you know significant numbers in enforcement over the same course of time that we’ve been building up our program. So uh, you know, I I would caution folks to think we need all of this staff in the building. I want to make sure we’re utilizing our taxpayer dollars efficiently, but of course we’re staffing up where it makes sense and relying on the exchanges and the um self-regulatory organizations. The NFA also does a fantastic job policing a lot of the activity when it comes to the brokers and the trading advisors. So we’re utilizing the entire ecosystem to make sure we do our job. Um, but but of course, uh we’re absolutely staffing up and building out our AI capabilities.
Bentsen: Right. So I want to turn to products and and and also coordination. So obviously, you know, prediction markets are growing rapidly in the U.S. Uh CFTC has been directly engaged in all that. Uh you know, we commented on uh both your uh AMP uh AMPR around prediction markets and then the uh joint request for comment with the SEC on definitions, thinking about product categorization uh coordination with the FCC on event contracts, and also uh um you know uh perpetual futures, single uh you know, uh single stock futures, which seem to be making a reprise, whether things are under CFTC, uh SEC jurisdiction, um, a lot of questions. I think the the the joint RFC was we think was very was kudos to you all for putting that out. You um you have the the uh uh the uh benefit of being able to speak both SEC and CFTC given your career. How are you thinking at the CFTC in terms of and and how you work with the SEC to determine whether something something is is a future and should be under your jurisdiction, or maybe it’s a security-based swap and it should be under the SEC? And and how should the market be thinking about that?
Selig: Well, we’re of course more harmonized as agencies, I think, than ever before. We’re working together very closely, and and that’s the most important thing because when we get an issue, whether it’s a product classification issue or uh things like cross-margining, you know, the staff need to be able to know who to call and be able to work through these issues together, and that’s exactly how the agencies are functioning today, which I think is a huge benefit to the investor community and the American people. Um but when when we’re looking at some of these various products, so we’ve seen an explosion of new types of products, and in part that’s because all of these prediction markets are unique. I think they’re offering KPI contracts and just about everything. They’re offering all sorts of uh up-down on stock prices and that sort of thing. And the the the interesting thing about our markets is that there’s so many different ways to express an economic opinion on whether it’s a stock price or a commodity price or an event occurring. And so that’s a great thing.
Selig: that that’s why our markets are so vibrant and we’ve got such a range of products. But as regulators, it’s always challenging to figure out you know, is this going into one bucket or the other? And oftentimes, if you look at our statutes, they’re they’re not a single statute, of course. So there are things that are not mutually exclusive in each statute. So you can have products that might involve a security, but they all also might be an event-based derivative on the CFTC side. And so last week or in the last few weeks, uh you all might have seen, for example, there were a number of uh KPI contracts that SIBO uh put up to list on its platform, and these were event contracts um that were uh structured as security options, and the SEC put out an order and an approval statement explaining that that’s not necessarily mutually exclusive with products on the CFTC side, because actually, if you look to our side, uh Cauchy and others have uh listed very similar products. And just because something fits within one definition on one side doesn’t mean you can’t have a very similar product trading on the other side. And so that’s the the harmonization, that’s really the the effort that the chairman and I, uh Chairman Atkins and I have really um pioneered. You know, we’re gonna work together to make sure that there’s competition in the markets, that’s our job as regulators, and that the products that have to be on one side and are supposed to be on one side are on the right side, of course. Um I sort of would envision it as more of a Venn diagram. There’s some products that sit in the middle that can arguably be listed on either side based on how they’re structured. Um, and so that’s exactly how we’ve dealt with some of those issues. Um but when it comes to some of these products that are, for example, security futures, of course we coordinate on that because those products are meant to be listed on a DCM or listed on an NSC with a notice registration on the other side. That’s always been a challenge, I think, for firms dealing with either agency, and that’s why we really haven’t seen a ton of these security futures products come to market. Now we’re seeing a huge influx because the agencies are working well together. So I I think that’s really important for innovation in the country.
Bentsen: Yeah, we we said in our letter to the uh joint request for comment that um you know uh the structure that was developed under the Commodities Futures Modernization Act, which I had some involvement in uh long time ago, uh may maybe didn’t consider things like uh uh perpetual futures. Um it definitely considered single soft futures because that was a key issue at the time. They didn’t really work, and and and you know, maybe maybe they’ll work now. Do you think that there do you think we may be at a period where Congress is gonna have to step back in and think about all right, the some of these new products maybe maybe don’t fit completely under the ambit what the uh you know the approval structure and jurisdictional structure was?
Selig: I actually do think that the statutes, whether it’s the securities laws or the the Commodity Exchange Act, contemplate a wide range of products. So I I think in that regard they’re they’re fairly evergreen, right? Uh the swap markets, I mean that was something that developed in the 90s, of course, and you could argue that the statute contemplated it, but there was this permissibility of allowing that to go off the exchange, and of course, then the statute was modified to permit that and then pull it back uh to some degree. But but I think with perpetual contracts, really what you’re looking at is just a futures contract, uh, or you could structure it, of course, as a swap. I mean, there’s no limitation. We’ve seen swaps convert into futures and futures convert into swaps. There they’re very similar products to some degrees, but if you, of course, check the box as a futures contract, you’re excluded from the swap definition. That’s how Congress dealt with that. Um I don’t think there’s any requirement in the statute to have an expiration date or anything like that. So maybe there’s some reason that you would have some additional regulation around it or treat it differently for certain purposes. But I do think the statute’s set up to accommodate that. Um it’s set up to accommodate options, futures, all types of swaps, contracts. So possibly, but but I but I do think we’re in pretty good shape.
Bentsen: So so we’re almost out of time, but um I have a little bit of authority, so I think we can go over a little bit. Um uh and I I I wouldn’t want us to finish without talking about the treasury market. Um there’s a lot going on there. Um as you know, SIFMA’s deeply engaged in the implementation of Treasury clearing, um uh getting the documentation done. You recently spoke at the Treasury Market Conference that the New York Fed host uh um uh and talked about the role the CFTC plays in the futures Treasury futures market, and that the agency must uh regulate differently given the changing market structure. What does regulating differently look like in practice?
Selig: Well, regulating differently really goes back to the points I’ve made throughout this discussion. We’re in a completely different world than we were 20 years ago. Our markets have totally changed. We’ve got tokenization 24-7, blockchain rails, stable coins, superintelligence, all you know, all these new innovations in our markets that are totally transforming the way that the treasury markets work as well. I mean, if if you were sitting here 20 years ago, I don’t think you would have predicted that uh the stable coin market would create this huge opportunity to export treasuries globally uh in the way that it has. So that’s really just a reference to how the markets have changed.
Bentsen: And and and um you’ve also noted uh talking about the impact of bank capital, we talked a little bit about Basel III Endgame at an earlier discussion. Um there’s a direct nexus between those capital rules and the Treasury futures market and the ability uh for you know cross-margin hedging that is gonna impact the Treasury clearing implementation. Are you are you talking with your fellow regulators, particularly the prudential regulators, about that and any interest you have in that?
Selig: Yeah, absolutely. So the the most important thing from our perspective is that the capital requirements under Basel uh actually are accounting for actual risk, right? Um so for so long, these have hung over the industry uh like a sort of Damocles, and I think that’s scared away all of the FCMs from uh offering services to many of the smaller farmers, ranchers, producers. You know, I think that’s really been detrimental to our markets because there’s so many commercial firms that are gonna use these markets for risk management purposes that are now not able to access the markets or have to put up excess money to be able to access one of these firms. And so we want to make sure that we’re actually looking at true risk, and this goes back, I think, to one of the comments they made earlier about the swaps regulations under Dodd-Frank. We really had this autoimmune response to the financial crisis. A lot of the reaction made a lot of sense and probably saved uh the broader system from further um implications of the crisis. But at the same time, some of the swaps regulations went too far, and I think that also undermined market activity. And so we’re looking at the same thing. We’re trying to work with the Basel uh with the prudential regulators to get Basel III right, um, and that means making sure that commercial firms have access to the markets that they need to hedge the risk uh and that we’re not placing too much of a an onus on uh the FCMs.
Bentsen: Chairman Sealing, thank you so much for spending time with us today. And uh uh you know, a lot going on in the short time you’ve been at the agency, and uh we look forward to seeing what uh comes next.
Selig: Absolutely. Thank you.
Bentsen: Thanks a lot. That was CFTC Michael Selig on responsible innovation and the importance of ensuring that regulation evolves alongside markets. Our next conversation continues that discussion from the securities markets perspective, looking at how the SEC is approaching modernization across a range of areas. Jamie Selway, director of the SEC’s Division of Trading and Markets, and Sebastian Gomez Averro, Deputy Director for Legal and Regulatory Policy in the Department in the Division of Corporation Finance, joined us for a wide-range in discussion on the Commission’s agenda. Their conversation covers tokenized securities and the SEC’s approach to testing new market models, along with extended trading, market structure, best execution, and the continued implementation of treasury clearing. They also explore efforts to modernize the public markets and support capital formation and how regulatory frameworks can adapt as technology, products, and market practices change. Here are Jamie Selway and Sebastian Gomez at SEPMA’s 2026 annual meeting. Chairman Atkins has set out a very ambitious agenda, um, and you’re two of the people that are doing the work to turn uh ideas into policy proposals. Um it’s been a very productive year across both your divisions. You know, from your vantage point, uh what has the what has the agenda done so far? You know, what has the agenda gotten done so far, and uh what do you think the top priorities will be over the next 12 months? Jamie, we’ll start with you.
Jamie Selway: Yeah, well thanks, Ken, and thanks uh SIFMA for for um for hosting us today. So the Division of Trading Markets has got really four uh priorities, and I think they’ll they’ll remain uh for the balance of the chairman’s uh chairmanship. Uh one is tokenized securities, uh second is harmonization with the CFTC, um, a third is 24 by 7 trading, and a fourth is just modernization of legacy rules. Um I think there uh progress has been made on on all four, uh maybe going through them quickly. Uh tokenized securities, I think we’re just on the innovation exemption, which I think we’ll talk about. We’re at sort of at a pivot point from use of exemptive authority, now moving to rulemaking. Uh harmonization with the CFTC is more of a newer project. We’ve got some RFCs we’ll talk about, but um you know that I think that’s gone well. I think you heard from Chair Steeliger earlier today. Uh 24 by 7 is is well ahead. Uh I mean we were um benefited from your round table earlier this year uh substantially, and now we’re looking at a big implementation date on on December 6th. And then in terms of monetization, I mean we’ve rolled off um some regular mess reform, transfer agent monetization, treasury clearing continues. I think we’ll talk about um business as such later. So I think um very, very busy, uh good progress, but uh plenty more to do. And frankly, if we had if Chairman Atkins had eight years, there’d be plenty to do with um with modernization uh efforts.
Bentsen: He he did work for a chairman who served eight years, maybe the last chairman that served eight years.
Selway: We could be so lucky.
Bentsen: Yeah, so Sebastian.
Sebastian Gomez Abero: 41:58
So um thanks for having us today. And by the way, um everything we say today is on our personal capacity, and we’re not speaking for the commission and the staff, you know, the the usual disclaimer, but just to put it out there. Um as you all know, uh there is a decline in the number of public companies, and we’ve also seen a trend in private companies staying longer private. Um so part of the chairman’s agenda is to look at what can we do in order to change the tide on that. And we all know here that whether a company goes public or not, or whether it stays public or not, depends on a number of factors. A lot of them are microeconomic factors that we at the SEC have no control over. But we do have control over one thing, and that is the regulatory landscape that those companies face when they go public and they want to stay public. So the chairman’s focus is to look at that regulatory landscape and see how we can modernize it, how we can refocus on the concept of financial materiality. And the Division of Corporation Finance has put out a number of recommendations, how they are, if you think about them, they actually all work in tandem with each other. The idea here is to look at what are the disclosure requirements that a company going public faces, both at the time of the IPO and then once they stay public. And how can we look at that and then take different bite-sized approaches to it? The first one that we did was we looked at the filer status release in order to look at how we can actually resize the type of disclosures that company needs to do. The chairman has indicated the next phase of that is looking at executive compensation disclosures. The next phase after that is looking at regulation SK, more specifically the business, the risk, and the governance provisions. But just looking at the disclosure itself is not sufficient. The other prong of it is looking at the capital needs that the companies face and understanding that the capital needs. Don’t end when a company goes public, but they continue thereafter and how we can actually support the ability of companies that go public to continue to tap those markets. We can talk some more about that later on.
Bentsen: So maybe I’ll follow up just on that because on the uh, as you noted, the chairman’s I think he’s quoted as saying make IPOs great again, but uh or maybe that was in his op-ed. Um
Selway: that’s actually a hat.
Bentsen: Yeah. There you go. And um so I mean the proposals, Sebastian, you’re talking about the registered offering proposal, I mean, really substantial, proposed substantial expansion of uh a lot of the Emerging Growth Company Jobs Act 1.0, not completely because Congress has to do some of that, but but what what what is within the Commission’s authority could have some pretty uh profound uh uh benefits. What you know the comment periods have closed on on the two big proposals. What and so obviously your you know your work, but are are you getting a lot of input from the issuer community and the investor community?
Sebastian Gomez Abero: Yeah, we are, and and just for those of you who are not totally familiar with with those proposals, when I refer to the filer status proposals, this is setting forth what are the categories of disclosure that applies to different groups of issuers. Today you have five different categories that an issuer could fall in: emerging growth company, accelerated, non-accelerated, smaller reporting company. And at times those five categories even overlap with each other. So the proposal is looking to simplify that into two categories: large accelerated filers, those are the issuers that have a public float of more than $2 billion, and then the rest of them would be non-accelerated filers. And it’s a nice way to then set forth the disclosure that I would apply to those different categories. Um, part of the proposal is also looking at how is it that the what we’ve learned from the emerging growth company accommodations and the smaller reporting company accommodations, how can we expand that? And then as a result of the proposal, if adopted, a lot of the companies, especially those mid-sized companies that today don’t get the benefit of some of those accommodations, will get some of those accommodations. Um, we also are proposing to create a new category for the smallest of the companies, just recognizing that if we want to incentivize those smallest companies to go public, we also have to provide an appropriate regulatory landscape for them. Um as far as comments on that one, uh we have received a number of comments. Uh, a lot of the commenters were very supportive on the $2 billion threshold for the largest of the companies. Keep in mind that as we design that $2 billion threshold, we look at how we can get the most impact when it comes to protections for investors, for those companies that account for the vast majority of the public markets that exist, that the public flow that is out there in the hands of investors, versus how we can maximize the number of companies that are below that threshold that actually account for a much smaller portion of it. So while the rules will actually capture a large number of companies within these accommodations, the actual public float of those companies that would benefit from this disclosure is much smaller, which means that the vast majority of investors will still be available to them, the protections that exist for the largest companies. With respect to registration reform, I do want to highlight this one because I think this one is going to be pretty significant change. Today, a company will do an IPO, think of a biotech company, goes through that entire process with the SEC, files a registration statement, gets comments from the staff, finally goes public on their IPO, and say four or six months later finds that their clinical trials got some great results, they’re going to need to raise additional capital in order to move on to the next stage of the clinical development. And guess what? They have to file another form S1 in order to do another follow-on offering, repeat a lot of the disclosure that was in that original registration statement, go through the SEC review process, and what we are asking ourselves in this proposal is do we need to subject the companies to that? The proposal, in fact, would allow a lot of these companies, all these companies to qualify for the short form S3 registration in order to be able to go public and then be able to tap those markets as they need after they go public.
Bentsen: Yeah, the expansion of the shelf registration is is is pretty uh pretty revolutionary, I think. I mean I know we have some comments around the edges on that. We don’t have to get into them here, but on on but uh but but that’s a major shift for sure. Um I I I want to uh one more thing before I go to Jamie and pivoting a little bit away from public markets to private markets. Um, you know, we at SIFMA have been uh commenting that that there should be greater access to private markets because private markets have grown, some of that at the expense of the public market, and some I think you know more evolutionary or organic, I should say. Um the Commission’s been thinking about this as well. And so you put out a proposal on modernizing the accredited investor definition. You put out a proposal on interval funds. Where are you going with all that?
Abero: Yeah, so for all of you familiar with the credit investor definition, for for a long time it has been focused primarily on income and net worth. And you qualify as a credit investor based on that. And absence of some small changes that the SEC did a few years back, the idea of sophistication is just not part of the definition, and that is something that we were looking to change with respect to these proposals. Um the concept here is can we actually allow someone to qualify to participate in one of these offerings, not just because they’re rich, but because they actually have the sophistication to do so. So the the proposed notices that we put out there contemplate a number of new ways that someone could qualify if you are if you hold a CPA license or if you are a CFA or a CFP. We also identified a couple of additional FINRA licenses that would qualify as an accredit investor. But probably most notable is the idea of a FINRA examination, uh, where any person would be able to go to FINRA and take an examination, a credit investor examination that FINRA is looking to develop, and then if they pass that examination, they qualify as an accredited investor. So many of you may be asking yourself, well, who would even take that? And as part of a lot of the feedback that we get at the SEC and we’ve gotten over time, I can see of two different categories of people who may be particularly interested in this. Um, one is young professionals. When you look at the definition today, um, many professionals that may actually meet the $200,000 income threshold, they don’t have the two-year look back to qualify for that. So you may start working and making $200,000 a year, advising clients on how to invest, and then at the same time, you’re not able to qualify as a credit investor yourself. So this will give them the ability to take a test and qualify that way. The other one is there’s there’s a number of people who live mostly away from the metropolitan areas in the center of the country, and where the income of a doctor or a dentist may not actually get you to that, but they are interested in supporting businesses in their community, and many of those businesses want to raise capital pursuant to REG D. So those would be another category of people. But to your point, this was not done in isolation. The Division of Investment Management proposed changes to rules that would actually allow individuals to invest in different types of uh pool vehicles at the same time that Corfin proposed these changes. And the idea here is not just create new accredited investors, but actually give them pathways to invest in diversified vehicles that will give them exposure to those private markets. So, for anyone interested more on that, um Brian Daly, our director of investment management, just gave a speech that describes the uh the thinking behind those proposals. And I think it’s uh something worth taking a look at.
Bentsen: Great. So let’s shift to uh uh Jamie and equity market structure. I think it’s what 22 years or so since Reagan MS. I mean formation started in the late 90s, obviously, but but but but it came to fruition.
Selway: Suppose 2005, I think um approved and implemented 2007.
Bentsen: Okay, And but the chairman has talked about uh making changes or perhaps getting rid of rule uh 611. There have been round tables, you all had a round table on it, uh uh maybe I had two round tables on it. Um and uh um um since then you you the commission’s put out a proposal uh to uh uh rescind 611 uh as and the locked and cross markets prohibition 610E. Um comment periods have closed, you’ve gotten a lot of comments, we’ve given you a lot of comments. Uh where does that stand? You know, what where do we think the commission, when do we think the commission is gonna act and and and uh where do you think you’re gonna end up to to the extent you can tell us, obviously.
Selway: Yeah, so two round tables last year, I think we had 1,200 comments, which is pretty heavy. Uh Sebastian had 270,000 for semi-annual, so we’re not uh quite up to snuff for that core fin colleagues. You guys got us beat there and we’ll and you can have it. Um and I think we’ve had excellent um engagement, you know, your your Equities Markets Committee uh and others uh from industry. So um we’re we’re pushing ahead uh with rescision, I think, with um with two important considerations based on the common file. One is um people industry folks were concerned that um without a uh sort of a tighter definition of an automated market, um, we might have like the the quality of the MBBO could erode. So we’ve taken um that to heart, and that’ll be part of our uh recommendation to the commission. Uh the other is the need for any change to 611 to happen you know, sort of contemporaneous with any with a modernization of best execution. And um best execution is is you know wonderful in its flexibility, it’s its principles-based nature. Um there’s lots of reasons to update best execution, not just 611, but also after hours trading, overnight trading, or you know, tokenization. Lots going on in the world. Um and we appreciate that um you know FINRA’s it’s a FINRA rule and it will remain a FINRA rule, uh, to the extent Chairman Atkins has got anything to say about that. Uh and we appreciate that we went first and FINRA came later, but uh trust that we are working you know hand in glove with them. Um I don’t know if Robert Cook spoke to your group um you know today earlier or uh
Bentsen: not not this year, but but we are certainly well engaged with them on the on on the on the best ex, yeah.
Selway: And he’s certainly reachable. But I I believe uh he would say you know they’ll do some guidance as an initial matter, contemporaneous with what we do on 611, uh, and then you know they may engage in rulemaking, but they they know that they need to flesh out their best execution thinking it’s an opportunity uh to be a membership organization, to be truly self-regulatory. I think they’re gonna take it. Um but I think that 611 for us uh is a is a Q1 event in all likelihood.
Bentsen: So it sounds like uh um I know uh my uh colleague Katie Colchin, who runs our equities committee, had commented at one of your roundtables uh the octopus nature of uh uh of Reagan MS. That um I don’t know if I’m gonna get my metaphor correct here, but somehow you’re taking into consideration the various tentacles of the octopus and how they all march in lockstep together going forward.
Selway: Without without going um you know, sort of uh too far down the the octopus hole, if that’s a word. Uh 611 touches uh our rules 610 and 612 and those rules were um adjusted by the Gensler uh SEC but not implemented. So you know we’ve exempted folks um you know for a two-year period. So we’ve got we’ve got some some business to attend to that. And you’ll be hearing more about that um along with uh any news on 611.
Bentsen: Okay, great. So you mentioned uh extended trading hours 24-7, or we call it 23-5. 23-5 is coming, I think, right? And it sounds like um obviously, I mean that’s a big thing for trading and markets, but corporate finance, corporation of finance has a role to play there too. But you know, um we’re spending a lot of time on this, obviously. And um there’s still a lot of things to work out, including in the corporation of finance, you know, the corporate actions, dividends, uh uh, how processes are gonna work. Are we gonna be at T1, T half a day, how’s you know, et cetera. How are you all thinking about it at the commission, Jamie? I’ll start with the
Selway: Maybe I’ll start. So um I think we feel pretty good about it. Uh, and in large uh part that’s due to some of the work that um you and your colleagues started the year with and end up been riding roughshod over over initially. It’s hard to herd the cats on all these questions. Uh DTCC went live with 23 by 5 trading in June. That’s huge. Um there’s been exchange testing. Um just a step back, what’s new here is exchanges offering 23 by 5 trading and there being public market data and clearing overnight. So that’s what’s new, and that’s what will go live on December 6th. There have been uh three or four ATS’s alternative trading systems operating uh, you know, formally but without um without making a public contribution to market data. So what we’re watching, uh I guess one would be probably two things primarily. One would be corporate actions, to your point. Corporate actions will now be compressed into the uh the hour pause between eight and nine Eastern. That’s a lot of work. Uh and corporate actions have been somewhat bespoke for a lot of years. So automating them and compressing them, uh, and then how do the issuers react to them uh to this sort of new regime will be interesting. That’s one. And then two, uh investor protection. There’ll be a limit-up, limit-down regime. You know, your colleagues can have also been incredibly helpful in getting that together by way of the exchanges, um, you know, to essentially um limit uh price moves overnight. So how that works in pr in practice, we’ll be we’ll be keenly watching that. I do think we’re gonna be at 24 by 7 um you know sooner than we can think. There was a public ATS announcement uh that they uh the Bruce ATS wants us to go live in November. They they couldn’t be persuaded to wait uh for December 6th. Uh they want to be live with 24 by 7. So uh we’re going to need to keep working through it. It’ll be, I’m sure it’ll consume much next year getting that right.
Abero: Two things from the issue community. If you haven’t started planning for this, you’re already too late, just go back and plan faster. Um but the other thing is if you are thinking about this and you find that some guidance from the Division of Corporation by Finance could be helpful as you are planning for this stuff. Our doors are open, reach out to us. We’re happy to to consider guidance that could help uh the transition in this space.
Bentsen: Do you think um I mean I and we’re gonna talk about tokenization in a second, but the uh and and a lot of this uh people suggest, I’m not saying the commission, but observer suggests that this is being driven by tokenization. But the uh and the crypto world, I guess, is a 24-7 world and to some extent. Um one thing we haven’t seen, and we it are round table that you participate in, you know, um the volumes really aren’t there, right? The it at least with respect to U.S. equities. And and just from your this is more your personal view from your experience, do you see with the exchanges coming in and all, do you do you think that’s gonna you know build it and they’ll come? Or
Selway: yeah, yeah, I mean the volumes right now are about one percent of the tape. That’s up from like you know, 20 basis points a year ago, two years ago. Um I think you can talk to sophisticated people that will say anywhere from you know maybe it grows a bit more but not much, up to five percent. We heard someone gave us a 30 percent number uh a couple weeks ago, which seems outlandish, but I think the answer is no one really knows. Oh look, I think it’s great for the country. I think um, you know, non-U.S. retail investors, particularly in Asia Pack, are just desperate to trade our our corporate issuers here, and that’s a good thing. We’ve got the deepest capital markets, we’ve got the broadest investor base, we’ve got the rule of law. Um, you know, I think um could we see non-U.S. corporates, you know, view our markets as a good place to raise capital, a better place to raise capital. That’s possible. So I think you know, we’ve got a substantial lead over the rest of the world, you know, as a as a global capital market. Um this is an opportunity to extend it in our view.
Bentsen: I do hear from my Asian colleagues certainly that there’s a lot of retail demand and and that. Let me um turn to tokenization digital assets. So moving quickly, as we all know, uh um on September 17th, the commission issued the long-awaited innovation exemption um granting the uh uh you know allowing permission trading of tokenized NMS stock through an automated market makers on uh uh tokenized security venues. Um uh we just submitted a list of a hundred or so questions to you um last uh uh earlier yesterday, I think it was. I think you all are now just putting out some FAQs. Um there are a lot of questions on uh and and give credit to the commission. You all have spent more than a year going through this and and and you and you’ve tolerated more than a dozen letters from us, but actually the dialogue has been very good back and forth. Um how from both of you all, how are you thinking, you know, wonder what are you hoping to to gain, what what kind of information are you hoping to gain from from this uh uh exemption? How are you thinking about protecting, you know, or maintaining the investor protection rules that exist in the in the markets today? And and then and then Sebastian, I want to also talk to you about sort of the issuer community, but maybe Jamie starting with you.
Selway: Yeah, I mean I think it is uh so we did do FAQs uh today. Uh we put out three, we also published a list of what are called tokenized security venues, uh, so we’ll maintain a list. These are you know venues that are um availing themselves of the innovation exemption. Um I mean we think it’s fairly measured, uh volume limitations requiring uh issuer negative consent to participate. Um we’ve had we’ve had three, I guess we have four out. One is OKX ICE as a joint venture. They’ve asked for 68 issuers. I think they’ve had 15 no’s, uh, they’ll launch in a couple weeks. There’s another one uh creatively named TSVLLC. They’ve got one issuer, um it’s a it’s a digital asset holding company, so that’s probably a yes. So we are we are going to see it. I mean, I think we thought, and the chairman feels strongly, that um finding a measured way to introduce this technology to the country’s capital markets is important uh to your question. We absolutely want to learn. We want to do something exemptive, collect data, see how the market reacts, uh, and then head to formal rulemaking. In terms of investor protection, I think issuer consent is a pretty good measure. I mean, we would want to put it all on issuers, but you know, clearly um you know, sort of the health of the investors near and dear to the issuer hearts. Um I think that um what some people are missing, all the protections that go with regular way trading, you know, halts, anti-manipulation and fraud regimes, best execution if you’re a broker, they’re still going to obtain here. Really what this was about fundamentally was allowing, you know, to the extent there’s true peer-to-peer trading, right? You know, true use by retail investors of digital asset wallets. They want to tokenize NVIDIA to sit right next to Bitcoin and Ethereum. That’s what this enables. Um it does not enable, you know, some wholesale repeal or end-around the best execution regime uh for NMSI.
Bentsen: So you’re saying that if if well a TSV is not a broker, though, right? They’re not a registered broker.
Selway: Unregulated anything.
Bentsen: Right. So they don’t have they don’t have a best ex obligation, at least as related to FENRU. But so where does SPS execution go?
Selway: If a broker-dealer wanted to trade on a TSV,
Bentsen: they would they would have that obligation. They would have a best execution rate.
Selway: That’s right.
Bentsen: And we don’t have to delve into it here, but but uh question was raised to me the other day, would a uh would a broker dealer’s best execution obligation in the traditional market be affected by a price that could be could be seen on a TSV?
Selway: Well that’s a great question for Robert Cook. But uh you know, one might take the view that um, you know, I mean best execution explicitly says clearing differences. Right. So if your client doesn’t have a wallet or isn’t isn’t interested in immediate settlement, if they’re not set up operationally to hold a tokenization, a tokenized asset, they’d have a pretty good argument that they could ignore it.
Bentsen: So, Sebastian, a a key issue that’s come up is uh uh we’re talking about issuer consent, and uh and we’ve heard a lot from our issuer members, our our members who are public companies, concerns about the impact, how it might affect their stock price if it’s fragmented, um, how just the notification process? I mean, that you know, how do they, you know, does a TSV just need to send a letter to them? I mean, uh what happens if they did that the mail gets lost or whatever? How you know what are you hearing from the issuer community on all that?
Abero: So we’re we’re hearing two topics. One one is the one that you just Mentioned and the order is pretty clear as to what the TSV has to do. And I think I encourage everyone to take a close look at the order, specifically footnote 64. In the order, it sets forth the process by which the TSV has to follow it, where it has to send the notification. I think a lot of the concern that we’re hearing is that the issuers are realizing that maybe they don’t have a complete control of what’s happening in the mailroom, and they’re a little concerned about what could happen if something gets sent to the mail room and they don’t see it for 30 days. We’re going to be working with Jim, Jamie’s team to provide a little more guidance in that space. But keep in mind that the issuer right now probably should be taking a trip down to the basement where it’s their mail room and having a communication with them to make sure that these notices get elevated appropriately within those 30 days. Because the key here is the issuer has a lot of control once they receive that notice. The issuer can say no, the issuer can pick one TSV and not another TSV. The issuer can say no and start a conversation with the TSV to see if maybe after they learn more, they actually change their mind afterwards. But the other topic that I think it’s it’s even more important, I think there’s a lot of misconception as to how this is going to impact corporate actions. And from my standpoint, I just don’t see much of the proxy plumbing changing at all. The reality is most of this tokenization is going to happen by a tokenization of entitlements. Today, if I hold shares through my brokerage account, all I have is an entitlement to the share. That share is immobilized in DTC. And what’s going to happen here most likely is going to be a tokenization of that entitlement itself. Nothing in the order changes Schedule 14A, nothing in the order changes the communications requirements and the delivery requirements to shareholders. So I think for most issuers, if they decide to do this, the process of dividends, the process of communications with the shareholder is going to be no different than it is today.
Selway: Could it guide you to say, Ken? I mean, we we we have to understand that we’re in a reality where offshore tokenization is being done to the issuer. They don’t have a say. You know, sort of folks are creating synthetics. Who knows what happens when things go sideways? So you know, the idea of reading them in, getting them involved, but it is absolutely our intention that the issuer, I mean, it’s probably a gamble that most issuers won’t, you know, wouldn’t take now, and we appreciate that. But giving some the opportunity to engage in an appropriate way with all the rights and privileges of the security flowing through to the token holders, as Sebastian said, I mean that just it just seems critical for the country to get it right here.
Bentsen: I want to move on. We have a little bit of time left. Now there are a few things I really want to get your comments on, uh and maybe do this quickly. Um interagency coordination, obviously, at the round table I participated in the joint round table. Um I know there’s a lot going on in the crypto digital world. Adjacent to that, though, um, and I was talking to Chairman Sealag about it today, we’ve got all these new products coming to market, like single stock futures, which is not a new product, it’s an old product coming back, uh perpetual futures. Some of the exchanges are trying to set them up on DCMs and then filing notice with the SEC. How are you all thinking about that? How are you all communicating uh uh with your brethren over at the CFTC?
Selway: We’re we’re communicating frequently and we’re in a bit of a hurry. So CME Dusted Off Single Stock Futures, that launched in July. So the marketplace has had some experience again, although it’s been limited. We have four uh perpetual uh futures on securities, four venues launching probably the first week of November, Calci Coinbase, uh Kraken’s affiliate, BitNomial, and Nadex Crypto.com’s affiliate. And it’s going to be on a pretty large swath of names. So um we’re working quickly really to create some monitoring regime. It involves NFA, uh, it involves FINRA. I mean, we’ve got joint authority with the CFTC on those products. So, I mean, I think our view is um, you know, investors seem to or seem very interested, the retail brokers are interested. These these products have shown value in the digital asset side, so uh it’s a potentially interesting innovation. We should facilitate it, uh, but but doing so in an appropriate fashion with investor protection is going to require uh we are kind of reinventing this regime uh because even though it was launched 25 years ago, it didn’t really um succeed then. Uh so giving it the opportunity to at least try now in a way that uh protects folks is uh that’s that’s really the that’s probably the most important thing that we uh the the most most important bit of joint action between us and uh the CFTC.
Bentsen: And and let me shift to uh treasury clearing, SEC’s rule mandating clearing of uh cash and repo. Uh cash will go at the end of this year, repo middle of next year, as you know. How do you feel about you know obviously we’re deeply involved in that. How do you feel about that right now?
Selway: We feel very uh good about cash. Um repo is uh is a complicated asset, uh esoteric to us at least. Um I think um you know your Dunaway letter uh or contract that’s incredibly helpful. Uh we’ve worked with you and your colleagues, Ken, closely on an affiliate exemption. We’re getting very close uh to that. Uh I suspect that we will still uncover after we move forward with cash, we’ll still uncover concerns around repo and we’ll take them as they come earlier next year. And I think we’ll be um you know thinking through uh so we’re absolutely intent on implementing next year, um, but you know, I think we’re we’re still in learning mode and we’ve got more to do. Um and I think look at the end of the day, um, it’s the single most important asset probably on planet Earth right now. Uh so um missing something and injecting a friction and treasury clearing is um tremendous consideration for us.
Bentsen: We don’t have time to get to the day, but I know we talked you referenced a little bit in the in the in the IPO research. Y’all are thinking about more issues yet, the safe harbor, but you’re you’re thinking about more areas uh making research great again.
Abero: Yeah, so um the Rich Drophen reform release would actually, as I mentioned, change who is S3 eligible. So a company would become S3 eligible immediately after the IPO. Um that is key because Rule 139 that provides a safe harbor for research report is available for S3 eligible companies. So today a newly reporting company would not be uh this the broker dealer would not be eligible to initiate coverage for that company for a year until that company is S3 eligible. So register offering reform actually changes that, making the safe harbor available to smaller companies and newly IPO companies. So the idea here is make sure that the safe harbor is there. That leaves it up to all of you to actually look at the business and the economics of research coverage and see if it makes sense. Um my hope is that we’ll see more research coverage among those newly IPO companies.
Bentsen: And uh e-delivery, you have a proposal. We
Selway: Yeah. In the bucket of streamlining e-delivery, you know, it’s a great collaboration with IM. You know, that that seems to be moving along quite nicely. Business as such. And CoreFIN, sorry, these are all to try trilateral. We all have to all
Bentsen: get along at the trilateral across the finish line. We get along,
Selway: we get along, we get along dangerously well these days. Um business as such, we’ve decided to break into pieces, do off-channel first, uh, and then um the more operational stuff second. Um I think in terms of research, I mean, there’s also a role for FINRA. Yeah. I would say, I mean, we’ve been anxiously awaiting a proposal from FINRA. Um and I would say that on the communications side, uh if there are flexibilities that are needed in terms of wall crossings uh you know between the research team and the um and the iBanking team, I mean, we should hear about it. These many of these rules, as this audience knows, I mean, they’re 20, 25 years old. It’s you know time for uh you know to revisit.
Bentsen: That’s great. Thank you all so much for uh uh spending some time with us. Today we could go on for a lot longer, but but but we need to we need to let you get back to work. And uh with that, we’re gonna have a break uh and we’ll be back here at 3.25. And thank you all again. You’ve been listening to two conversations from SIFMA’s 2026 annual meeting featuring CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig and SEC leaders Jamie Selway and Sebastian Gomez Aberno. Taken together, these discussions underscore a central question facing the capital markets: how regulation can keep pace with innovation while preserving the investor protections, market integrity, and resilience that underpin strong U.S. markets. As markets continue to evolve, that will require clear and appropriately calibrated rules, coordinated across regulators, and a willingness to modernize frameworks as technology and market practices change. For more from SIFMA’s 2026 annual meeting, including additional sessions on demand and the SIFMA Insights annual meeting debrief, visit SIFMA.org.