Barbara Roper’s Factual Inaccuracy

Published on:
February 27, 2015
By:
  • Kenneth E. Bentsen Jr.

By: Kenneth E. Bentsen Jr.

Barbara Roper’s recent blog post this past Tuesday entitled “Industry to DOL: (Don’t) Mind Your Business” is not factually accurate.

Roper asserts that my statement, “the brokerage industry is highly regulated by the SEC and FINRA, including with respect to retirement accounts” is “irrelevant and wrong” because the Department of Labor (DOL), not the SEC and FINRA, has exclusive rule-writing authority under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).

We do not contest the DOL’s rule-writing authority. However, it is equally clear and unarguable that the SEC and FINRA have plenary authority and jurisdiction over all aspects of broker-dealer conduct and accounts, including without limitation IRAs. Dodd-Frank reemphasized the point in passing Section 913. FINRA highlighted it again when issuing Reg. Notice 13-45.

Bottom line: in the midst of a retirement crisis, the DOL’s fiduciary re-proposal will take away a middle class investor’s choice of working with a highly-regulated financial advisor at a time when they need retirement advice the most.

Kenneth E. Bentsen, Jr.

President and CEO

SIFMA

Details

More Content

  • Press Releases
    Nov 16, 2026

    Deloitte and SIFMA Release White Paper on Digital Cash and the Future of US Securities Settlement

    Deloitte and SIFMA released a whitepaper exploring the integration of digital cash across the U.S. securities settlement lifecycle.
  • Press Releases
    Nov 12, 2026

    SIFMA Fixed Income Market Close Recommendations in the U.S., the U.K., and Japan for Thanksgiving Day

    SIFMA confirmed its previous recommendations for the U.S., the U.K., and Japan in observance of the 2026 U.S. Thanksgiving Day holiday.
  • The SIFMA Podcast
    Nov 06, 2026

    Market Snapshot: What’s Ahead for the Economy and Markets? Featuring Steve Liesman, Scott Anderson and Mark Zandi

    meta description for this? Hear Steve Liesman, Scott Anderson and Mark Zandi discuss the 2027 economic outlook, GDP growth forecasts, Fed policy and key market risks on SIFMA's Market Snapshot.

Get the latest trends, stats, and research on financial markets and securities.