The Aggregation of Position Limits

Published on:
February 10, 2014
Submitted to:
CFTC
Submitted by:
SIFMA AMG

Summary

The Asset Management Group of SIFMA (SIFMA AMG) provides comments to the CFTC on the proposed rulemaking, Aggregation of Positions, RIN 3038-AD82.

SIFMA AMG believes that the CFTC has made some positive steps in this 2013 Aggregation NPRM, but has some significant concerns with respect to certain aspects of the proposal, and shares their recommendations in the following areas in particular:

  • Owned Entity Aggregation;
  • Investment in Accounts or Pools with “Substantially Identical Trading Strategies;”
  • Passive Investors in Commission Regulation 4.13 Exempt Pool Aggregation Requirement; and
  • Independent Account Controller Exemption.

Excerpt

Melissa Jurgens

Secretary

Commodity Futures Trading Commission

Three Lafayette Centre

1155 21st Street, N.W.

Washington DC 20581

Re: Notice of Proposed Rulemaking – Aggregation of Positions (RIN 3038-AD82)

The Asset Management Group (“AMG”) 1 of the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association (“SIFMA”) appreciates the opportunity to provide the Commodity Futures

Trading Commission (the “Commission”) with comments regarding the “Aggregation of Positions” proposed rulemaking (“2013 Aggregation NPRM”). 2 We believe that the Commission has made some positive steps in this 2013 Aggregation NPRM, but we have some significant concerns with respect to certain aspects of the proposal, in the following areas in particular:

  • Owned Entity Aggregation. The Commission should not adopt the owned entity aggregation as proposed. Requiring passive investors, which include, without limitation, registered and private commodity pools and other investment vehicles, pension funds and other institutional clients of asset managers, that have no control over, or even knowledge of, the specific commodity derivatives trading activities of owned entities they have invested in to aggregate the positions of such entities would impose significant costs that would unnecessarily diminish their ability to provide valuable capital investment and generate returns for their beneficiaries and participants, exceeds the scope of the Commission’s position aggregation authority under the Commodity Exchange Act (“CEA”), and is an unwarranted departure from the Commission’s historical aggregation approach. The proposed exemptions from this owned entity aggregation requirement under proposed rules 150.4(b)(2) (10 to 50% ownership) and (b)(3) (above 50% ownership) do not sufficiently address the flaws of the proposed approach to aggregating owned entity positions in the passive investment ownership context.

Continue Reading >

Details

Download

More Content

  • Letters
    Nov 09, 2026

    Political Contributions by Certain Investment Advisers (SIFMA AMG)

    SIFMA AMG supports the SEC’s proposal to rescind the investment adviser pay-to-play rule, citing compliance burdens, costs and restrictions on political speech.
  • Letters
    Nov 09, 2026

    Political Contributions by Certain Investment Advisers

    SIFMA comments on the SEC’s proposal to rescind the political contributions rule for investment advisers, citing compliance burdens and existing safeguards.
  • Amicus Briefs
    Nov 06, 2026

    Blockchain Assoc. and Crypto Council for Innovation v. IL

Get the latest trends, stats, and research on financial markets and securities.